Change the Conversation: what SME owners should really be asking
Ask most small business owners about private medical insurance and you tend to get one of two reactions. Either “we can’t afford it”, or “isn’t that just for people who want to skip the queue?” Both are fair enough. Neither is quite the right question.
I have been in business for a long time, and the owners I respect most treat healthcare the way they treat the van: they would rather know it works before the day they need it. This article is about changing the starting point of that conversation, from “the NHS is struggling” to “what would I actually like my team to be able to do when they are unwell?”
Why the waiting list is the wrong place to start – To Change The Conversation
The waiting list is real. NHS data released on 12 November 2026 showed it rose to 7.38 million in September, a third monthly increase in a row. If you run a business, you already know this. You have probably heard it at the school gate, in the pub and from a customer who has been waiting for a knee for longer than they have been waiting for a kitchen.
But leading with it has three problems.
First, it is a number everyone has already heard, so it stops landing. Second, it is a moving target. It goes up, it comes down, and every time it falls someone says the case for private cover has gone away. Third, and most importantly, it tells you nothing about what you would actually get. Frightening people is not the same as helping them.
So here is a better set of questions.
Access, choice and ongoing support
Access. When someone in your team feels unwell, how quickly can they speak to a clinician, get a referral and get a scan? Not in theory. On a Tuesday, with a deadline on Thursday.
Choice. Who do they see, where, and what exactly is included? Cover levels, excesses, hospital lists and outpatient limits vary more than most people expect, and the differences are the whole point of having someone compare them for you.
Ongoing support. Who is in your corner after the policy is bought? When someone needs help with a claim, or when the renewal letter arrives and the price has moved, who picks up the phone? This is the part most people forget to ask about until they need it.
The everyday bits are what people actually use
Hospital admissions are, thankfully, the exception. What most members use is the everyday end of the policy. Three areas are worth a closer look.
Digital GP
A video or phone appointment with a GP, often the same day, is now included with many policies. Insurers report that usage has risen sharply since the pandemic, and VitalityHealth says 71% of authorisations in its 2025 claims report were started online. For a small team, the value is simple: a problem gets looked at on day one rather than day ten.
It is worth being straight about one thing. Easy access to a GP can lead to more referrals for tests, which is partly why claims and premiums have been creeping up. That is not a reason to avoid it. It is a reason to understand what you are buying.
Diagnostics
This is where the NHS figures are hardest to ignore. At the end of July 2026, 443,200 patients were waiting six weeks or more for one of the 15 key diagnostic tests in England. That is 23.1% of everyone waiting, against a standard of less than 1%.
For an employee, a scan that is booked quickly can mean the difference between a worry that lasts a week and a worry that lasts two months. Plenty of small business owners tell us that the “not knowing” costs more than the absence itself. Check how each policy handles diagnostics, whether a referral is needed, and what the outpatient limit is.
Mental health
The Office for National Statistics estimates that 148.8 million working days were lost to sickness or injury in 2025, around 4.4 days per worker. Trade press analysis of the same data puts mental health conditions at roughly 17.1 million of those days. In a survey of 500 HR professionals by Everywhen, 59% of employers ranked staff mental health as their top concern.
For a team of eight, that is not a statistic. It is a person you know. Policies differ widely here: some offer fast access to talking therapies without a GP referral, others are narrower. It is one of the most useful things to compare.
What to ask when you compare
These are the questions we would put to any plan, whether it is new or one you already have.
- Is there a digital GP, and are family members included? It matters because the person who needs it is not always the employee.
- Can staff self-refer for mental health support? It matters because waiting for a GP appointment first can add days or weeks.
- Are diagnostics covered on an outpatient basis, and what is the limit? It matters because this is where many people first meet their policy.
- How is the premium likely to move at renewal? For smaller groups, pricing can be partly based on claims experience, so mid-sized employers can see more movement than larger ones.
- Who handles claims queries and renewals? It matters because a policy is only as good as the help you get when you use it.
The honest bit
Private medical insurance is not a replacement for the NHS, and a good broker will tell you so. In general it covers acute conditions that can be treated and resolved, not long-term chronic conditions or emergency care. Pre-existing conditions are often excluded or underwritten. Premiums have been rising, because claims have been rising, and some employers have reported renewal increases well into double figures.
That said, the market has grown for a reason. The latest LaingBuisson analysis puts the number of people with access to private medical cover, once dependents are included, at a record 8.1 million, or 11.8% of the UK population. People are not buying it because it is fashionable. They are buying it because they want choices on a bad day.
Where we come in
We look after the plan for you, which means we do not disappear once the paperwork is signed. If you are buying cover for the first time, we will talk it through in plain English. If you already have a plan, we are happy to review it and, if you would like, manage it from there. That includes the dull but important job of looking at it again at renewal.
If you would like a straightforward chat, give Jacob a shout. No pressure, no jargon, and we promise to mention waiting lists no more than once.
Insure My Health is a trading style of Parkway Mortgages Ltd, an Appointed Representative of The Right Mortgage Ltd, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England & Wales Number: 6748364
Sources
- NHS wait list sees third consecutive monthly increase, COVER magazine, 12 November 2026
- Diagnostic Waiting Times and Activity Statistical Report, July 2026, NHS England
- Sickness absence in the UK labour market: 2025, Office for National Statistics, published 1 May 2026
- UK sickness absence data 2025: what the latest figures mean, Clifton Ingram (mental health days lost, drawn from ONS data)
- Providers called to enable proactive mental health support, COVER magazine (17.1 million mental health days lost in 2025)
- Mental health still most pressing concern for employers, Health & Protection, reporting the Everywhen survey of 500 HR professionals
- VitalityHealth 2025 Health Claims and Insights Report, as reported by Corporate Adviser
- What factors are driving private medical insurance claims?, Employee Benefits
- Record numbers turn to private healthcare insurance amidst long NHS waits, Healthcare Management, reporting LaingBuisson analysis